10 Best Organic Lipsticks for Your Lips: Ultimate Beauty Picks in 2024

GlamGrader collection-of-organic-lipsticks

Finding the Best Organic Lipsticks for Your Lips
The allure of organic lipsticks lies in their composition. Formulated with natural oils, butters, and waxes, they often avoid synthetic chemicals and preservatives that can be found in traditional lipsticks. As we make more eco-conscious choices, the demand for beauty products with clean, organic ingredients rises. Organic lipsticks offer a range of benefits, from moisturizing properties to a lighter environmental footprint, making them a favored option for those looking to beautify sustainably.

When shopping for the best organic lipstick, you should be mindful of the ingredients. Look for products with certifications like USDA Organic or EcoCert to ensure that the ingredients meet strict organic standards. Additionally, the pigmentation, longevity, and feel of the lipstick are key factors to consider. Since natural pigments can behave differently than synthetic ones, it’s important to find a lipstick that delivers the desired color payoff and staying power without compromising on the organic promise.

In the spirit of informed purchasing, we’ve carefully chosen and thoughtfully tested a selection of organic lipsticks. We evaluated their performance, ingredient purity, and overall appeal to bring forth a list that stood out making them the best lipstick choices for this year. This guide will navigate you through the market’s top options, ensuring that your choice not only enhances your beauty but also aligns with ethical and health-conscious standards. Let’s look at the lipsticks that have earned their place at the top in the past year, blending nature’s best with stunning colors and textures.

Best Organic Lipstick for Your Lips: Ultimate Beauty Picks

In our search for the best organic lipsticks, we’ve meticulously evaluated and tested a wide array of products to bring you this curated list. Each lipstick boasts nourishing ingredients, a commitment to natural beauty, and an unwavering dedication to ethical standards. With a focus on shade range, longevity, and skin-friendly formulations, these lipsticks stand out in a saturated market. Dive into the world of organic beauty with us as we present our top picks for the year.

#1 Honest Beauty Goddess

We think that if you’re seeking a lipstick that balances vibrant color with nurturing ingredients, Honest Beauty’s Goddess is the ideal choice to consider.

Pros:

✅ Employs avocado oil and hyaluronic acid for hydration
✅ Formulated without common irritants; EWG Certified
✅ Offers a balance of lasting color and a cruelty-free ethos

Cons:

❌ The matte finish may not appeal to those who prefer a glossier look
❌ May not be as long-lasting as some non-organic counterparts
❌ Some users may find the scent unpleasant or the color different from expectations

Honest Beauty’s Goddess lipstick is a standout for its commitment to clean beauty. The infusion of avocado oil and hyaluronic acid provides the lips with much-needed hydration, making it an attractive option for those of us prone to dry lips. Moreover, its EWG Certification reassures us that it’s free from many harmful additives found in other lipsticks.

In an industry swarming with options, what sets Goddess apart are their vegan and cruelty-free credentials. These ethical considerations resonate well with us, as we are conscientious about animal welfare and ingredient sourcing. Plus, the velvety matte finish offers a sophisticated look that’s on par with the more expensive and fashionable lip colors.

On the downside, while the matte liquid is designed to last, it might fall short of the 6-hour claim for some, requiring a touch-up. This could be a minor inconvenience for us who lead busy lives and prefer a low-maintenance beauty routine. Furthermore, those of us with a keener sense of smell might find the natural scent less appealing, and the color may vary on different skin tones.

Given these insights, Honest Beauty’s Goddess seems best suited for eco-aware buyers who prioritize organic formulas and ethical production over industrial endurance and artificial fragrance.

#2 Burt’s Bees Glossy Lipstick

We believe this lipstick is suited for those seeking a balance of color and lip care, thanks to its natural ingredients and luscious pink hue.

Pros:

✅ Infused with moisturizing oils for smooth lips
✅ Natural, eco-friendly ingredients
✅ Rich pigmentation with a glossy finish

Cons:

❌ Not as long-lasting as some may prefer
❌ Some users reported inconsistency in texture
❌ May not suit those looking for a matte finish

Burt’s Bees is well-known for their commitment to natural beauty, and their Glossy Lipstick in Peony Dew is no exception. The combination of Red Raspberry Oil, Moringa Oil, and Meadowfoam Seed Oil works to hydrate and nurture your lips, a standout feature for those of us who value lip health alongside aesthetic appeal. A deep pink with a tasteful hint of cinnamon provides your lips with a fresh pop of color that’s noticeable but still within the realm of naturally enhancing your lip color.

Comparing it to other organic lipsticks on the market, the lustrous glossy finish that this lipstick delivers sets it apart from often more subdued matte counterparts. Its formulation without parabens, phthalates, petrolatum, or SLS makes it a highly attractive pick for the eco-conscious buyer. The fact that it comes in recyclable packaging further solidifies its position as a sustainable beauty option.

In the wider context of the Top Organic Lipsticks on the market, this Burt’s Bees option offers a beautiful equilibrium of vivid color and moisturizing properties. Whereas some lipsticks might excel solely in pigment or endurance, Peony Dew strikes a comfortable balance. Users will enjoy the creamy texture that doesn’t compromise on coverage. However, those of us in search of a long-wear lipstick might note that Peony Dew may require touch-ups throughout the day to maintain its glossy look, which isn’t uncommon for lipsticks focusing on a natural formulation.

#3 PPZ Organic Lipstick Set

This PPZ Organic Lipstick Set marries natural ingredients with vivid colors, ideally suited for eco-conscious beauty enthusiasts.

Pros:

✅ Crafted with quality natural ingredients
✅ Rich, moisturizing formula that soothes the lips
✅ Palette offers six colors for versatile styling

Cons:

❌ Some users reported receiving duplicate colors
❌ Waterproof claim may not hold up for all users
❌ Mixed feedback on the ingredient’s authenticity

Organic products, particularly in the beauty industry, are in high demand as more of us seek cleaner, more sustainable options. The PPZ Organic Lipstick Set is a great fit for those who prioritize natural ingredients without compromising on a variety of color choices. With hues ranging from bold reds to soft plums and energetic corals, it caters to diverse aesthetics and offers flexibility for different occasions.

The inclusion of natural oils and beeswax in the lipstick’s composition not only ensures an eco-friendly product but also offers a moisturizing experience. This is a significant advantage for individuals with dry or sensitive lips who are looking for makeup that also cares for their skin. A matte finish promises a contemporary look that aligns with current beauty trends.

While this lipstick set ranks well, it’s not without its downsides. There have been instances of dissatisfaction regarding color duplication and the authenticity of the organic claims, suggesting a closer look at quality control might be needed. Despite these concerns, the positives seem to outweigh the negatives, especially for those who value an organic blend.

Comparing this set to others on our list, it stands out for its commitment to natural, organic components in a space that’s often filled with synthetic counterparts. We recognize this set for its ability to offer moisture-rich and varied tones—a hybrid that is sometimes rare in the world of organic lip products. However, when considering customer feedback, the product could benefit from an enhanced verification process to assure users of its ingredient authenticity and variety.

#4 Burt’s Bees Russet River

For buyers seeking natural ingredients in their makeup routine, Burt’s Bees Russet River offers both vibrant color and moisturizing benefits.

Pros:

✅ Emphasizes natural, moisturizing ingredients
✅ Free from parabens, phthalates, petrolatum, and SLS
✅ Award-winning shade range and lasting color

Cons:

❌ May require additional lip balm for extra hydration
❌ Color may differ from digital images
❌ Some users report texture inconsistencies

The allure of Burt’s Bees Russet River lies in its commitment to 100% natural ingredients. Its moisturizing qualities are a direct result of beeswax, moringa oil, and raspberry seed oil, making it stand out for those of us who prefer eco-friendly and skin-nourishing options. Vitamin E serves as a bonus antioxidant, which we find crucial in protecting our lips on top of adding color.

Given the range of 18 shades, this lipstick is versatile enough for different tastes and occasions, allowing us to enhance our natural lip color or make a bold statement. The Russet River shade, in particular, is a standout warm, dark chocolate hue that has even won a 2016 Allure Best of Beauty Award, suggesting its popularity and appeal.

We are mindful that online images cannot replicate the exact color on every screen, and thus the lipstick may look different upon arrival. Some buyers have also experienced the need for additional lip balm to maximize hydration, which may not be ideal for those of us looking for a one-product solution. And while robust for most, a few have reported the texture to be less than smooth in application.

This satiny Burt’s Bees lipstick is best for buyers who prioritize natural makeup and want substantial color payoff without compromising on lip care. Despite the few drawbacks, it’s generally well-received for its nourishing formula and range of shades. The recyclable packaging further strengthens its position as a sustainable choice in our daily beauty regimen.

#5 Fifth & Skin BOTANICAL Lipstick

We consider this Fifth & Skin lipstick a top contender for anyone seeking a vibrant Berry Red color with ethical production standards and organic ingredients.

Pros:

✅ Infused with natural vitamins and essential oils for enhanced lip health
✅ Free from harmful chemicals and cruelty-free, aligning with ethical consumerism
✅ Long-lasting color payoff, avoiding frequent reapplication

Cons:

❌ May not be as moisturizing as some users desire
❌ Color variations may occur due to screen differences, potentially leading to unexpected hues
❌ The matte finish might not appeal to those who prefer a glossier look

When it comes to organic lipsticks, few can hold a candle to the nourishing blend of botanicals, vitamins, and minerals Fifth & Skin offers in their BOTANICAL line. This BERRY RED matte lipstick stands apart with a true, dark red color that suits a wide range of skin tones while also being environmentally conscious and health-friendly.

Amongst its most impressive assets are certified organic ingredients like shea butter and jojoba oil, which provide lips with a moisturizing treatment. Moreover, antioxidants in this lipstick offer protective benefits, which is something we always seek in our beauty products.

In regards to performance, a critical edge this lipstick has is its durability. Unlike many organic options that might wear off quickly, this one boasts a lasting color. Additionally, the fact that it’s crafted without toxins makes it a prudent choice for us who prioritize our health without compromising on performance.

While most buyers will cherish the lush Berry Red shade, we need to mention that the color might vary slightly from screen to computer screen. It’s a detail to consider if we’re specific about the precise shade. For a natural, cruelty-free choice, this Fifth & Skin BOTANICAL lipstick is ideal for us who value quality and ethical considerations in our makeup.

#6 Mom’s Secret Lily Lipstick

We believe discerning customers looking for vegan, cruelty-free cosmetics will appreciate this lipstick for its organic ingredients and natural finish.

Pros:

✅ Infused with Vitamin E for moisture
✅ Contains Organic Grapeseed and Jojoba Oils
✅ Made in the USA with a commitment to cruelty-free practices

Cons:

❌ Only available in a limited range of shades
❌ May not be as long-lasting as non-organic alternatives
❌ Has an average customer rating suggesting varied experiences

Organic lipsticks are carving out a significant niche in beauty circles, and Mom’s Secret Lily Natural Lipstick is no exception. This product stands out for incorporating nourishing organic components that promise to enhance the health of one’s lips. Its blend of Vitamin E with organic oils provides a hydrating experience without employing harsh chemicals.

Shoppers who prioritize ethical beauty standards will find comfort in knowing the lipstick is vegan, paraben-free, and not tested on animals, aligning with more compassionate consumer values. Moreover, it aligns with an eco-conscious lifestyle, providing an added benefit for those looking to make environmentally friendly choices.

Considering our collective insights, this lipstick is particularly fitting for someone who values natural ingredients, and ethical manufacturing processes and is looking to support American-made products. Its blend of key features such as natural oils and vitamins sets it apart from other options on the market. However, it’s important to weigh the importance of longevity and color range, as more traditional lipsticks might offer better performance in these areas. Overall, Mom’s Secret Lily Lipstick is a commendable choice for those inclined towards organic beauty.

#7 Honeybee Gardens Queen Bee

We recommend this lipstick for its balance of vibrant color and natural, nourishing ingredients.

Pros:

✅ Rich, matte signature red shade
✅ Infused with organic oils for lip hydration
✅ Long-lasting color performance

Cons:

❌ The lipstick may break if not handled carefully
❌ Texture might vary depending on individual lip characteristics
❌ Color perception may differ from the provided images

Honeybee Gardens’ Queen Bee offers a standout red that could be a staple product in any makeup enthusiast’s collection. Infused with high-quality organic oils, it’s designed not only to adorn lips with a stunning matte finish but also to provide considerable hydration, potentially eliminating the need for a separate lip balm.

The color payoff of Queen Bee is robust, setting it apart from other organic options that might fall short in pigmentation. Its long-lasting formulation means fewer touch-ups throughout the day, an advantage for those with busy lifestyles. When it comes to finding an organic lipstick that does not compromise on color quality, this might be exactly what you’re searching for.

Considering the competitive landscape, Queen Bee holds its ground with an impressive blend of performance and quality. While some may find the shade differing from online images—a common occurrence in online cosmetics shopping—this shade offers a classic red that suits varying skin tones. The application experience, according to users, is also smooth and doesn’t drag, which is notable amongst its organic peers.

In conclusion, our take on Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Lipstick, Queen Bee, is that it’s an excellent option for someone who prioritizes a natural formula without sacrificing the luxuries of traditional lipsticks. The product’s emphasis on sustainability and quality, paralleled with the high-intensity color it brings, makes it a valuable contender in the lineup of top organic lipsticks this year.

#8 Physicians Formula Organic Spice

Physicians Formula’s Organic Wear Lipstick in Spice is a thoughtful choice for those who prefer makeup with nourishing ingredients.

Pros:

✅ Infused with natural oils for hydration
✅ Free from harsh chemicals, dermatologist-approved
✅ Eco-friendly and suitable for sensitive skin types

Cons:

❌ May not be as long-lasting as some conventional lipsticks
❌ Texture may be too soft for some preferences
❌ Potential color discrepancy from screen to real-life

Our top 10 roundup calls for special attention to lipsticks offering more than a flash of color. Physicians Formula Organic Wear stands out with its dedication to moisture, combining the benefits of shea butter, coconut oil, and jojoba oil. A noticeable difference from others in the list is its antioxidant Vitamin E, which not only beautifies but also protects.

When selecting an organic lipstick, it’s crucial to assess more than just the shade. This particular product is perfect for those who prioritize skin health and are seeking a lipstick that loves your lips back. It’s eco-conscious without sacrificing the vibrant color payoff—traits that are not always mutually inclusive.

There are common hurdles with organic makeup, and Physicians Formula is no exception. It trades longevity for gentleness, making it less resilient throughout the day than some synthetics. Furthermore, while the velvety texture is a luxury, those accustomed to a firmer stick might find this one challenging.

To sum up, we believe this product fits beautifully within a mindful beauty regime that champions ethical choices without compromising on color. It sits well amongst its peers, striking a balance between lipstick and lip care, a duality highly sought in the organic beauty space.

#9 L’Oreal Paris Colour Riche

For those chasing everyday elegance with a touch of nourishment, this lipstick won’t disappoint.

Pros:

✅ Blends Argan Oil and Vitamin E for moist lips
✅ Offers a broad palette for every occasion
✅ Receives glowing reviews for its creamy texture

Cons:

❌ Not the longest-lasting option
❌ Some shades might not appear as expected
❌ Discontinued items can be hard to replace

L’Oreal Paris Colour Riche Lipstick stands out with its luxurious blend of nourishing ingredients that keep our lips soft and supple. A spectrum of 52 shades caters to every mood and style, ensuring that there’s a color for all of us. With such a vast palette to choose from, we’re able to express ourselves for any occasion, from the boldest reds to the most understated nudes.

The creamy, hydrating formula is enriched with Argan Oil and Vitamin E, which sets it apart from many other lipsticks that can leave lips feeling dry. Yet, it’s the infusion of these caring elements that make it a standout, ensuring our lips are not only colored beautifully but cared for too.

We’ve noticed the product scores highly among users, often praised for its smooth application and comfortable wear. This reaffirms its place as a top choice, especially for those of us seeking a lipstick that doesn’t compromise lip health for color pay-off. Despite not being the longest-wearing option, its creamy texture, and skin-friendly ingredients make it a worthy addition to our makeup collection.

#10 Hemp Organics Bronze Lipstick

Pros:

✅ Formulated with 95% certified organic ingredients
✅ Kiss-proof longevity with a shimmery bronze finish
✅ Free from petro-derived dyes, catering to health-conscious users

Cons:

❌ Limited to one shimmery bronze shade that may not suit all skin tones
❌ Some may find the consistency or shimmer less appealing
❌ Not as widely available as other brands

For those seeking a natural shimmer and a commitment to organic ingredients, this bronze-hued lipstick is a solid choice.

Organic lipsticks are designed to offer both beauty and peace of mind. This particular product balances the two by incorporating high-caliber organic ingredients that not only deliver vivid color but also nourish the lips. It’s made in the USA in small batches, which further reassures us of its quality and craftsmanship.

In a saturated market, Hemp Organics Bronze Lipstick stands out by offering a golden bronze shade, which is especially flattering for sun-kissed or darker skin tones. It’s an ideal choice for buyers who prefer their beauty routine to be as natural as their lipstick. The long-lasting formula ensures color stays put, and its unique combination of organic beeswax and plant wax seals in moisture, keeping lips soft.

We understand different consumers have varying preferences when it comes to their makeup. While this lipstick boasts ingredients that cater to a more naturally inclined audience, its unique color may not be the everyday go-to for everyone. However, its formulation is geared toward those who place a premium on organic and clean beauty.

In conclusion, Hemp Organics Bronze Lipstick secures a position in our top organic lipsticks list due to its dedicated use of organic components, robust pigmentation, and moisturizing properties. Its singular bronze shimmer serves as a standout option for those looking to make a statement while maintaining an organic beauty regime.

Buying Guide – Best Organic Lipstick for Your Lips

Criteria to Consider

GlamGrader Best Organic Lipstick for Your Lips

When selecting the best organic lipstick for your needs, we must consider several key criteria:

Ingredients: Aim for lipsticks with natural, organic ingredients. Look for certifications like USDA Organic or ECOCERT to confirm the quality and sourcing of the ingredients.

Pigmentation: Ensure the color payoff meets your expectations. Some organic lipsticks may use natural pigments that are more subtle than synthetic ones.

Durability: We want lipstick that lasts throughout the day without frequent reapplication. Check for customer reviews on wear-time.

Comfort and Feel: Good organic lipstick should feel comfortable and moisturizing, not dry or heavy. Ingredients like beeswax and shea butter contribute to a smoother application.

Shades and Finishes

There is a variety of shades and finishes available, and it’s essential to choose according to personal preference:

  • Matte: For a flat, non-shiny look.
  • Glossy: For a wet, reflective finish.
  • Satin: For a balance between matte and glossy.

Price vs. Quality

GlamGrader Best Organic Lipstick for Your Lips

We must balance cost and quality. More expensive does not always mean better, but with organic ingredients, a higher price point often reflects the sourcing and purity of the components.

Ethics and Sustainability

Consider the ethical practices of the brand, including:

  • Cruelty-free testing
  • Sustainable packaging
CriteriaWhat to Look For
IngredientsCertifications, natural sources
PigmentationDesired opaqueness and hue
DurabilityLongevity and wear-time
Comfort and FeelMoisturizing ingredients
Ethics and SustainabilityCruelty-free, eco-friendly practices
We must evaluate these factors carefully to find the best organic lipstick that suits our preferences and lifestyles.

Verdict: The Best Organic Lipstick for Your Lips

After meticulously testing and comparing various organic lipsticks, we’ve selected one that stands out from the rest. Our choice for the Top Organic Lipstick of the Year is the Aria Pure Lipstick by Hynt Beauty. This lipstick is celebrated for its high-quality ingredients and performance.

  • Performance: It provides long-lasting color and hydration.
  • Ingredients: It contains organic ingredients, such as castor seed oil and jojoba.
  • Shades: A range of shades suitable for all skin tones.
  • Certifications: It boasts certifications like cruelty-free and vegan.

*Aria Pure Lipstick* not only delivers rich pigmentation but also takes care of your lips with its nurturing formula. Our selection is backed by customer reviews and ingredient analysis, ensuring that we recommend a product that our readers can trust and love.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, we address common inquiries about organic lipsticks, focusing on their composition, packaging, certification, color trends, and identifying non-toxic options, as well as exploring homemade solutions.

What defines lipstick as 100% organic?

A lipstick is considered 100% organic when all its ingredients are derived from organic sources, without synthetic additives, pesticides, or chemicals. The entire production process is subject to strict organic standards.

How can lipstick be eco-friendly in terms of packaging?

Eco-friendly lipstick packaging is achieved by using materials that are recyclable, biodegradable, or derived from sustainable resources. Brands may opt for bamboo, cardboard, or glass instead of conventional plastic.

Knowing that a third-party organization has certified the product as organic, can this instill confidence in its authenticity?

Yes, third-party certification from organizations like USDA, Ecocert, or COSMOS can strongly validate a lipstick’s organic status and reassure consumers of its authenticity and adherence to organic guidelines.

What are the top picks for natural lipstick colors this year?

The top picks for natural lipstick colors this year emphasize earthy tones, soft pinks, and subtle reds, reflecting the industry’s trend towards hues that enhance the lips’ natural color while embracing organic formulations.

How can consumers identify lipsticks that are free from harmful chemicals like parabens and lead?

Consumers can check the ingredient list for certifications such as ‘paraben-free’ or ‘lead-free’ and look for absence claims or seals from reputable organizations. It’s crucial to be vigilant about the presence of these ingredients in product descriptions.

Are there any DIY methods for creating natural lipstick at home?

Yes, there are DIY methods for creating natural lipstick using ingredients like beeswax, coconut oil, natural pigments, and essential oils. These homemade options allow individuals to craft lip colors tailored to their preferences without harmful chemicals.

Authors

  • Denise Macgiver

    Denise has an extensive background in cosmetics and makeup artistry and has owned her own business as a beautician along with her work as a private contractor for the film and movie industry and for ad agencies.

    View all posts
  • Alice Slater

    Alice trained as a cosmetologist at Glen Dow Academy in Spokane, WA. She was a representative for "Beauty for All Seasons" for several years and worked for numerous ad agencies and production companies as a freelance makeup artist. She also served as a volunteer for Spokane Ballet and the Spokane Symphony doing makeup and hair.

    View all posts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top