Nyx Gloss Review: Shining a Light on the Latest Lip Shine Craze

NYX Butter Gloss GlamGrader

Among the variety of lip gloss brands available on the market, NYX has established a niche for itself, especially with its line of lip glosses that cater to a wide array of preferences and styles. Lip gloss has long been a beauty staple for those seeking a lustrous finish to their makeup look, offering a subtle color and sheen that can enhance the natural beauty of the lips. Unlike lipsticks that provide an opaque and matte coverage, lip glosses are known for their shine and sometimes even a plumping effect, imbuing a sense of fullness to the lips.

NYX glosses, in particular, are praised for their diverse range of shades, consistency, and affordability, making them accessible to makeup enthusiasts regardless of their budget. They are formulated to glide on smoothly, leaving a glossy finish without the stickiness that can be a common downside with other lip glosses. NYX has ensured that there is a shade and finish, be it glittery, metallic, or creamy, for everyone in their expansive lip gloss line.

When deciding to purchase a lip gloss, the most important factors to consider are the formula, staying power, and the applicator shape. A good lip gloss should provide hydration to keep the lips comfortable throughout the day and should last for a significant amount of time without the need for constant reapplication. The applicator plays a crucial role as well, it should allow for precise and even application, defining the lips without causing the gloss to go outside the lip line. After thorough personal testing and analysis of customer reviews, I’ve found that certain NYX glosses stand out from the rest in these areas.

To sum it up, NYX glosses are designed to cater to a variety of aesthetic preferences with an impressive range of shades and finishes, combined with a formula that balances shine and hydration. These attributes make the NYX gloss line a compelling choice for anyone looking to add a splash of glamour to their makeup routine without compromising on comfort or quality. Now, let’s take a closer look at some specific products from NYX and see how they hold up under scrutiny.

Top NYX Gloss Picks

I’m excited to share my favorite NYX gloss options that not only deliver on shine but also provide a stunning color payoff. Whether you’re searching for a subtle shimmer or a bold statement, there’s a NYX gloss to satisfy every preference. Get ready to elevate your lip game with these top picks that have personally caught my eye for their comfort and lasting power.

#1 NYX Butter Gloss

I think this gloss is a delightful choice for anyone who loves a touch of color with a comfortable wear.


✅ Gloss provides sheer to medium coverage
✅ Nonsticky and creamy texture
✅ PETA-certified cruelty free brand


❌ Might need reapplication throughout the day
❌ Limited to sheer to medium coverage
❌ Some might prefer more sustainable packaging

NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss has a reputation for its lusciously smooth application. It’s known for the way it simply glides over the lips, imparting a sheer to medium coverage that can complement any makeup look. The variety of shades available makes it easy to find one that enhances your natural lip color or adds a bold pop to your pout.

When I consider the standout features, the nonsticky consistency seems to be a major win. It’s refreshing to find a lip gloss that doesn’t leave a tacky feeling, allowing for a comfortable wear throughout the day. Furthermore, the fact that this product is acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty free brand aligns with ethical consumerism, making it an even more appealing choice for buyers.

Who is this lip gloss perfect for? I’d argue it’s ideal for someone who enjoys a polished look without much effort. The gloss can be easily slipped into a pocket or purse, making it convenient for on-the-go touch-ups. It adds a hint of color while moisturizing the lips, so it’s fantastic for everyday wear.

Lastly, affordability without compromising quality is another commendable aspect of the Butter Gloss. It’s proof that you can have high-performing makeup without a steep price tag. Customers often seek products that deliver both value and performance, and this one fits the bill.

#2 NYX Professional Fat Oil Lip Drip

If you’re in search of a lip gloss that delivers both color and shine without the usual stickiness, this might be the perfect match for you.


✅ Offers up to 12 hours of hydration
✅ Versatile use, either alone or over other lip products
✅ Proudly cruelty-free


❌ Glossiness may not last all day
❌ Color intensity could be too sheer for some
❌ Limited color range in this collection

When I examine the NYX Professional Fat Oil Lip Drip, a couple of traits distinguish it. This lip gloss infuses lips with hydration, thanks to the inclusion of vegan squalane, making it ideal for those seeking to avoid dry or chapped lips. Furthermore, the gloss offers flexibility in application; wear it alone for a subtle glow or layer it atop your preferred lipstick for a boost in intensity.

Another standout aspect is the stance on animal welfare, NYX Professional Makeup is certified by PETA as a cruelty-free brand, which means you can enjoy this lip gloss with a clean conscience. The range of eight universally flattering shades ensures that there’s a match for various skin tones and makeup styles, making it a versatile choice.

The Fat Oil Lip Drip does have a few downsides. While it offers long-lasting hydration, some users might find that the shiny finish doesn’t endure throughout the day and may need touch-ups. Additionally, the sheer tint of the gloss could be underwhelming for those who prefer a more vibrant color payoff. Lastly, although the available shades aim to cater to a broad audience, the selection isn’t vast, so some might not find their perfect shade within this line.

In sum, this lip gloss by NYX Professional Makeup is an excellent fit for the conscious beauty enthusiast who values moisturizing benefits and a cruelty-free commitment, alongside the versatility of a gloss that can be worn solo or paired with other lip products for enhanced effect.

#3 NYX This is Milky Gloss

If you’re seeking a blend of hydration and tasteful tint for your lips, the NYX This is Milky Gloss might just be your go to pick.


✅ Offers up to 12 hours of hydration
✅ Cruelty-free formula with vegan milk infusion
✅ A delightful range of milkshake-inspired shades


❌ May require reapplication throughout the day
❌ Some users report inconsistency in texture
❌ Color may appear different online than in person

Lip gloss enthusiasts seeking a cruelty-free, hydrating option will be intrigued by the NYX This is Milky Gloss. As someone who values both ethical makeup choices and moisturized lips, I find this product appealing for its use of vegan milk and the promise of long-lasting hydration.

The diversity in shades inspired by different milkshake flavors allows for playful experimentation. Whether you’re craving a subtle splash of color or building up layers for a bolder look, this gloss aims to cater to your mood and style. The sweet scent is an added bonus, enhancing the sensory experience of your lip makeup routine.

Staying power is an important aspect of any lip product, and the NYX This is Milky Gloss might need a touch-up now and again, especially if you’re someone who sips coffee or snacks frequently throughout the day. Yet, its lightweight feel may balance out the need for occasional reapplication. It’s worthwhile for beauty lovers who prioritize comfort and a nonsticky finish.

The NYX This is Milky Gloss stands out due to its unique blend of hydration and flavor, setting it apart from less moisturizing alternatives. If you often find lip products to be drying, this formula could offer the quench your lips need. Remember, though, that the color may vary from what’s seen online, so be prepared for a bit of surprise upon delivery. Overall, it’s a sweet treat for your makeup collection that doesn’t compromise on ethical standards.

#4 NYX Fat Oil Slick Click

I think if you’re in the market for a vegan lip balm that provides a pop of color along with hydration for your lips, the NYX Fat Oil Slick Click is a great choice.


✅ Infused with nourishing oils like avocado and raspberry
✅ Vegan-friendly and cruelty-free
✅ Provides hydration for up to 12 hours


❌ Some people may find the click-up packaging annoying
❌ Glitter presence in the balm might not appeal to everyone
❌ Limited color payoff compared to traditional lipsticks

As someone who prioritizes lip care, I appreciate the NYX Fat Oil Slick Click not just for its ability to keep lips hydrated, but also for its commitment to being a cruelty-free brand. This lip balm stands out with its vegan formula, enriched with essential oils like avocado, cloudberry, and raspberry, ensuring your lips stay nourished. I find that it’s perfect for buyers who want a multitasking product that cares for their lips while adding a hint of color for an everyday look.

While the idea of a high shine finish might sound appealing, it’s worth noting that the NYX Fat Oil Slick Click doesn’t just offer a gloss, it brings a nonsticky, balmy texture that’s comfortable for prolonged wear. The buildable nature of this product allows you to control how light or bold you want your lip color to be, which is a plus for me when I’m going for a more natural aesthetic.

However, if you enjoy the experience of swiping on your lip products, you might not be a fan of the click-up packaging that dispenses the product. It’s different, and while it’s designed to give you just the right amount, it can be annoying for some. Moreover, let’s talk about the sparkle; there’s a bit of glitter in this balm, and depending on your taste, this could be a delight or a deal-breaker.

In conclusion, the NYX Fat Oil Slick Click is a strong contender if you’re searching for an eco-conscious lip product that also doubles as a light cosmetic. Its oil-rich formula is a standout compared to other balms, offering a soothing embrace for your lips throughout the day. However, the unique packaging and the subtle glitter might not be everyone’s cup of tea, but it certainly adds character to an already charming product.

#5 NYX Plumping Lip Polish

I think this gloss is perfect for those who want a glamorous shine with a plumping effect without the commitment of lip injections.


✅ Non sticky formula for comfortable wear
✅ Cruelty-free product, ideal for ethical buyers
✅ Variety of shades to complement any skin tone


❌ May not provide significant plumping for everyone
❌ Limited staying power; frequent reapplication needed
❌ Tingling sensation might not be comfortable for all users

If you’re in the market for a lip gloss that gives a subtle plump and dazzling shine, the NYX Professional Makeup Filler Instinct Plumping Lip Polish could be your go-to. Its sheer formula is quite versatile, working well on bare lips or as a top coat over your preferred lipstick.

The cruelty-free aspect of NYX’s lippies is a feature I admire. It’s becoming increasingly important for many to ensure their beauty routine is ethically sound, and this gloss complies with that.

Among its top features, the Filler Instinct Plumping Lip Polish boasts light-reflecting emollients that not only provide shine but also a perception of fuller lips. This stands out, especially when compared with other glosses that might offer shine without the additional benefit of a plump look.

Would I recommend it? Absolutely, especially for my peers who wish for a pouty look with cruelty-free assurance. Remember to apply it regularly though, as its staying power may not take you through an entire evening without a touch-up.

Buying Guide

Understanding Your Preferences

Nyx Gloss GlamGrader

When I’m picking out a lip gloss, I first consider the look I want. Glosses come in various finishes: sheer, satin, and glitter. Sheer gives a subtle shine, satin offers a bit of color, and glitter makes a sparkly statement.

Texture and Feel

Comfort is key. Some glosses are sticky, while others are smooth. I check the reviews to see what others say about the formulation.


I look for nourishing ingredients like vitamin E and jojoba oil which care for my lips. I avoid glosses with too many chemical additives that I’m not familiar with. It’s better to be safe with what goes on my skin.

Applicator Type

Nyx Lip Gloss GlamGrader

The applicator affects the ease of use. Doe-foot applicators are my usual go-to for precision, but a tube with a built-in applicator can be convenient for quick touch-ups.


I prefer a gloss that lasts well but is also easy to remove. Some glosses have longer staying power which is ideal for long days.

Key FeatureWhy It Matters
FinishDetermines the look I’m going for
TextureAffects comfort and wear throughout the day
IngredientsImpacts lip health and gloss quality
ApplicatorInfluences the ease of application
LongevityHelps me know how often I’ll need to reapply

Price Point

Nyx Lip Gloss GlamGrader

Finally, I consider the price. I balance cost with quality to ensure I get a good value without breaking the bank. A higher price doesn’t always mean better quality, so I read reviews and compare before making a decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, I’ll address some of the most common questions you might have about NYX lip glosses, from color selection to application tips.

What are the most popular shades of NYX Butter Gloss?

My personal favorites among NYX Butter Gloss shades include Creme Brulee, a lovely nude; Angel Food Cake, a plush mauve; and Praline, a deep brown. These shades cater to a range of skin tones and are perfect for everyday wear.

How long can I expect NYX lip gloss to stay on?

Based on my experience, NYX lip glosses typically last for a few hours. They may need reapplication after eating or drinking, as they’re not entirely transfer-proof.

What are the benefits of using NYX Butter Gloss on my lips?

NYX Butter Gloss offers a smooth, buttery texture that feels comfortable and hydrates my lips. It also provides a sheer to medium coverage, which enhances the natural color of my lips without feeling sticky.

Can you provide tips on how to apply NYX Shine Loud Gloss for the best results?

For flawless application of NYX Shine Loud Gloss, I start by exfoliating my lips. Then, I apply the base coat evenly, allow it to dry for a bit, and finish by layering the glossy topcoat for a high shine effect that doesn’t budge.

What is the difference between NYX Butter Gloss and NYX Glossy Fat Oil?

While NYX Butter Gloss is known for its creamy consistency and sweet scent, offering sheer to medium coverage, NYX Glossy Fat Oil delivers a pop of color with a shiny finish and is enriched with oils for added hydration.

Has NYX Cosmetics discontinued any of its lip gloss lines recently?

So far, I haven’t noticed NYX Cosmetics discontinuing any of their lip gloss lines recently. They seem to maintain a consistent offering, albeit with periodic releases of new shades or limited editions that might replace older ones.


  • Denise Macgiver

    Denise has an extensive background in cosmetics and makeup artistry and has owned her own business as a beautician along with her work as a private contractor for the film and movie industry and for ad agencies.

    View all posts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top